A speaker says: 'Ignore her proposal about school hours, she failed her own exams.' Which fallacy is this?

Answer and explanation

Correct answer: C. Ad hominem: it attacks the person instead of the proposal

  1. Step 1: The speaker never discusses the proposal on its merits. Step 2. He rejects it because of a personal fact about the person who made it, which is an ad hominem attack. Answer: Ad hominem: it attacks the person instead of the proposal. Why not the others: A straw man misrepresents the idea, a bandwagon appeals to numbers, and a slippery slope predicts a chain of consequences; none of them happens here.

Practise more Language, Grammar and Rhetoric.

Free questions with an explanation for every one, and full timed Pancyprian Examinations (Cyprus) mock tests.