A student takes another student's umbrella from a stand, intending to use it for a day and then return it. Is he guilty of theft?
Answer and explanation
Correct answer: B. Probably not, as he intended only a temporary taking, though section 6 could apply if he treated the umbrella as his own
- Step 1: Theft requires intention to permanently deprive under section 6.
- Step 2: Borrowing is not theft unless the borrowing is equivalent to an outright taking.
Answer
Probably not, as he intended only a temporary taking, though section 6 could apply if he treated the umbrella as his own.
Why not the others: Temporary taking alone is not theft; belonging to another is only one element; umbrellas are property.
Practise more Property offences, inchoate offences and defences.
Free questions with an explanation for every one, and full timed SQE1 (Solicitors Qualifying Examination) mock tests.
More Property offences, inchoate offences and defences questions
- Which of the following is the actus reus of theft under section 1 of the Theft Act 1968?
- Applying the test in Ivey v Genting Casinos as adopted in R v Barton and Booth, how is dishonesty determined in a criminal case?
- Dee takes a handbag from a woman by grabbing it and pushing her to the ground. Which offence is most likely?
- Greg enters a shop as a customer intending to steal. He steals some goods. Which offence is he most likely to commit under section 9(1)(a) o…
- Which offence is committed by a person who dishonestly makes a false representation intending to make a gain for himself or cause loss to an…
- For the offence of attempt, what is required of the defendant's act under the Criminal Attempts Act 1981?